A dinner for S?

Carville: Collective room IQ went up .7 points when he entered.

Carville: Collective room IQ went up .7 points when he entered.

There are two events for Montana Democrats that I know about – the Harry S. Truman Dinner, and the Mansfield-Metcalf dinner. Last night was the latter in Helena, with guest speaker James Carville.

I attend the Truman Dinner in Billings in 1996. Many make light of the fact that Truman’s middle initial stands for nothing. I don’t.

Oliver Stone has done some intriguing work regarding Henry Wallace and Harry Truman – that is, how did this little-known Missouri haberdasher become FDR’s vice president in 1944? The answer, according to Stone, was back-room dealing and treachery. Truman became possibly the worst president in American history, clueless in being duped into dropping atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki (he thought the former, according to historian Howard Zinn, to be a military base*). He also signed enabling legislation that gave us the CIA and NSA. He would lament these deeds in a ran-only-once (afternoon edition) 12/63 editorial in the Washington Post, but far too late. Wheels set in motion in 1947 had culminated in the death of a president one month earlier. Truman might have known this.

So we have the beginning of the Cold War, the Korean War, the NSA/CIA and beginnings of the military industrial complex, all under the governance of one man, S.

Democrats, clueless about history, clueless about politics, honor him.

Politics us hard enough to understand on ground level, but for leaders like those of the Montana Democratic Party and their guest speaker, Carville, less so. There were a thousand Democrats at the M-M dinner, and when Carville entered the collective room IQ went up .7 points. Those party faithful seated in the room, and this is true of all partisan politics, are searching for validation. They want but two things out of politics: moral and intellectual superiority. Fighting the mean old Republicans gives them both.

Of course, the same is true on the other side of the street. I don’t know what Republicans do – a Reagan/Bush/Bush dinner? Same game, different name.

Partisans do not understand issues, have no sense of history, and honor men and women of low integrity based on a simple letter by the name. Nothing matters but that Grant Park sense of superiority. In the end, it all comes down to winning on election night. For partisans, an electoral victory is the Tour de France, the Superbowl, World Series, Stanley Cup, Oscar and Peoples’ Choice, all rolled into one. It’s an orgasmic frenzy. It’s nirvana, the rapture. It’s Woodstock – with toilets.

I am harder on Democrats than Republicans, naturally leading the latter to think I am really a Republican mole. It’s more than that.

Republican leaders can get in a room, high-five one another and say “Hey, friends! No need to pretend. We’re all Benghazi crazy here.” They bask in ideological purity. They actually held George H.W. Bush accountable when he violated the “no new taxes” pledge.

Democrats, on the other hand, have to pretend to care about things they disdain – universal health care, civil rights, peace, the commons – they can’t be natural, cannot be themselves even when among the herd. It’s a constant state of tension and lies. This easily explains the stuttering Max Baucus, unable to relax unless, gavel in hand, he was arresting doctors and nurses. There is no accountability of office holders in a party with no governing ideology.

It’s interesting in one sense – Republican leaders are not nearly as crazy as they make out to be. In politics, all public behavior is for effect. Much of what they say and do is aimed at the Democratic base, gauged to get a reaction and keep the two-party myth alive. Democrats, on the other hand, have to play-act for the same base more than the “other” party. So in essence, most of the stage play called American partisan politics is done for the benefit of the Democrats.

And it’s time those Democrats knew – they are neither morally nor intellectually superior to anyone. The only way to get rid of that not-so-fresh feeling is to leave the party.
*8/9/45: Excerpt from public statement by President Truman. This was the second time he had publicly given reasons for using the atomic bomb on Japan: “The world will note that the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima, a military base. That was because we wished in this first attack to avoid, insofar as possible, the killing of civilians.”

About Mark Tokarski

Just a man who likes to read, argue, and occasionally be surprised.
This entry was posted in American wilderness, Democrats, Political campaigns, Politicians. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to A dinner for S?

  1. Big Swede says:

    Carville quote.

    “The voter is basically dumb and lazy. The reason I became a Democratic operative instead of a Republican was there were more Democrats that didn’t have a clue than there were Republicans.”


    • Interesting. If you can cite that quite, I’d be appreciative.

      I see in Carville high intelligence, which is why I noted that when he entered the room the collective IQ went up. But I am so naive myself that I cannot imagine how he and so many other party leaders are basically living a lie.

      But then, George Constanza, when Jerry said to him one day that he’d be living a lie if he did something he shouldn’t, said it was no big deal, as at any given time he’s got half a dozen lies going. That’s how operatives live and work, in both parties. It’s so disheartening to see the state of the species. Everything around and about them is a lie, and they don’t care.


    • All right, I found it. It seems genuine. And the beauty of it is that he has a sound barrier around him – Democrats will never hear his words, as they are indeed clueless.


      But don’t get too uppity, Swede. I’ve met many politically clueless people in my life, and about half of them are Republicans. You’ve got insight into them, they’ve got insight into you, all of you know nothing of your own selves.


  2. Pingback: A Democratic consensus for America | Piece Of Mind

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s