Green Party Prevails at 9th Circuit Court

It’s been a long wait.  I was a plaintiff in this lawsuit to strike down Montana’s unconstitutional election laws. 

On November 8, the Federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals issued an Opinion in Montana Green Party v Jacobsen, 20-35340. It struck down the unequal signature distribution requirement that has existed for Montana petitions for new party recognition ever since 1981.  The unequal distribution requirement was responsible for the Green Party’s petition failure in both 2018 and 2020.  The three Judge panel rendered an opinion written by Judge Fletcher, which held that the case was not moot because of the change in the law, found that the District Court was correct on the First Amendment claim, but reversed the District Court as to the 14th Amendment claim as to the Equal Protection violation in regard to the discriminatory signature requirements in the State House districts.  https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2021/11/08/20-35340.pdf

The original dispute was a result of the removal of all the Montana Green Party’s candidates from the general election ballot in 2018 by the Montana Supreme Court. The Supremes upheld the District Court’s Opinion, which removed Greens from the 2018 ballot over a small number of “irregular” signatures in several voting districts.  The Democratic Party filed suit to protect Senator Tester from my U.S. Senate campaign as a Green Party candidate.  After signatures had all been “certified,” and I had won the Primary election to become the Green Party’s nominee, Democrats filed a lawsuit to eliminate any competition from a “real left” challenge.  Way back in January, 2019 I wrote a piece right here at POM on the lawsuit, and its possible implications.  I was wrong about 2020.  The Green Party and its candidates were again removed from the competition.  Democrats scream bloody murder about “voter suppression” against ethnic minorities but are never tagged with voter suppression when it comes to Green Party candidates and ballot access manipulation to protect its left flank, which is usually exposed for all to see.  https://pieceofmindful.com/2019/01/09/montana-green-party-clears-another-ballot-access-barrier/#more-82011 

I was wrong about 2020.  The Green Party and its candidates were again removed from the competition. There’s always 2022 for those still enthralled with electoral politics. 

Only Arizona and Iowa remain as states that maintain unequal distribution requirements for candidate or party petitions.  Neither state’s distribution requirement has ever been challenged in court.   

Why did Democrats do it?

Q.  “Now, if the Green Party qualifies for ballot access, how is the Montana Democratic Party affected?”

A.  “We would have to put more resources on the ground to knock on different doors than we normally would.” “We would have to put out more expensive, more complicated polling.”

“We would have to hold more fundraisers, spend more resources trying to gather more money to pay for all of these things.”

The above quote is taken verbatim from a court recording during a hearing held by the Montana First Judicial District County of Lewis and Clark on May 17, 2018.

Well, that concludes my involvement in electoral politics.  Boring, I know. That’s more than enough for one lifetime.  I wouldn’t say I’m going out on a high note, just going out, never to run again, or vote again for that matter.   What I have learned in a not so gentle way, I suppose, is that politics is irrelevant.  That’s just how I see it at this point.  There are no winners in politics, just losers.  It’s a little embarrassing to look back at all that energy wasted, but it seemed like a good idea at the time.  And we did scare the shit out of Sen. Tester for a few months before being dispatched by Hillary Clinton’s crack team of lawyers, who descended on little ole’ Montana and set everybody’s mind right.  Mine will never be right. 

The doctor said I might get better, but I’ll never get well…  I’m gonna’ keep on boogyin’ till they roll me in a hearse….  King Biscuit Boy with Crowbar 

2 thoughts on “Green Party Prevails at 9th Circuit Court

  1. Excellent post, Steve! It follows both your and my journey through electoral politics. I spent days and hours collecting signatures to get Nader on the ballot in 2000 (many thought I was advocating for Rob Natelson … that worked too, a signature is a signature – am I corrupt too?) (Rob Natelson was a right wing force in Montana during those years before semi-retiring to the Colorado School of Mines.)

    Nader’s candidacy, now easily seen to be a farce, was a separate mission, to derail the Green Party nationally.

    We can also deduce by injection of $2 million in dark money into the 2012 Tester campaign, using the Libertarian Party to pull votes away from Dennis Rehberg, that 1] Tester is corrupt, never having polled 50% or more in an election, getting Greens off the ballot was merely a replication of the Libertarian Party stunt to protect his flimsy following, since Greens would have deducted votes from him, and 2), Rehberg, whose father was an outstanding man, might well have been a decent man too, I don’t know. Many times the sons of good people are pale carbon copies (the mother often dominates in the formation the child). and 3), they were actually counting votes that year.

    With the full implementation of electronic voting, I do not imagine that any election outcome is reliable. Most don’t matter, but all can be changed behind the scenes if needed. I doubt Biden carried much beyond CA and NY, the rest (including his Super Tuesday miracle) done by chicanery. We are in full blown fascism now, easy apparent.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. In 2002, I won the Democratic primary and nomination, ultimately running and losing to Dennis Rehberg by a wide margin in the general. I raised $18,ooo as I recall, receiving almost 33% of the votes cast. Cheapest cost per vote ever.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s