The U.S. government is running massive deficits in its general fund, which includes interest on the debt, the military and its many wars and weapons programs, government infrastructure and some social welfare programs. This deficit could be alleviated by increases taxes in those areas where taxes have been cut, and economic upturn. To allow it to bleed is irresponsible in the extreme, but the leadership of the two political parties are controlled by the sectors whose taxes need to be increased, and so are incapable of action.
So we get distraction instead. According the latest Trustees’ Report on Medicare and Social Security, those two programs have surpluses that might run out in thirteen years (Medicare) or twenty-five years (Social Security). (By the way, when the Social Security Trust Fund expires, as it was designed to do, Social Security will still be able to pay pensions. It will simply not have a surplus to draw on.) New forecasts say that slower than expected economic growth shortens the projected life span of these programs.
Forecasts are a planning tool, but should never be thought of as reliable beyond one year, and so should be revisited often and used only for near-term planning. Those who predict crises beyond five years should be treated as we do Christianity – publicly observed but otherwise not taken seriously. No one knows what our state of affairs will be next year, much less in 2036. The law requires the Trustees to keep an eye out for future trends regarding the two programs, but doomsday predictions are mere political rhetoric used to advance political agendas.
Rep. Paul Ryan has put forward a plan to move senior citizens from Medicare to private insurers, supplying them with vouchers. This is lunacy, as the private insurance system is hardly affordable for healthy people, much less seniors who consume most of our health care dollars. (If private insurers were a positive social value, the government would not have had to step in the 1960’s to form Medicare.) We spend our working years fighting with these leaches, and they refuse to deal with any of us who are aged, possibly having a medical condition that might threaten profitability, or too poor to afford their premiums. The private insurance system simply does not work, as it is in conflict with itself: It cannot both feed investors and perform the social function of providing reasonably priced health care to all citizens. It needs to be scrapped. It is hugely inefficient.
Medicare is indeed a looming problem, however. It is not its structure, but rather its reliance on the private sector, that creates that problem. Private health insurance has created a bureaucratic nightmare, with 31% of our medical expenditures required merely to decide who pays (more properly, who doesn’t) the bill. Single payer would fix the problem, of course, or at least heavy regulation of private insurers, outlawing their ability to profit off of basic medical care. But because free market economics is a religious, rather than rational belief system, those who preach it know no other answer and are bound to keep trotting it out to solve every problem.
Likewise, private pensions are weak sisters of government cousins. The notion of a “defined benefit,” which is the basis of Social Security, was discarded decades ago. The system was gradually converted to defined contribution – the 401K,s IRA’s and SIMPLE’s which are subject to annual fees that drain at least a quarter of their reserves over the long haul (Social Security: 3%.) Once a worker relies on his 401K for retirement, he is daily confronted with the possibility that it will be drained before he dies. “Security” does not exist in private pensions, whose funding is rarely secure for twenty-five years. Libertarians and Randians decry inter-generational transfer, but they have not a leg to stand on in offering secure alternatives. It may offend their senses, but they ought to do as most religious people do – worship on Sunday and live in the real world the rest of the week.
Ayn Rand died reliant on Social Security for income and Medicare to treat her lung cancer, both courtesy of her husband, Frank O’Connor, whom she openly disrespected. She ought to be buried in an unmarked grave somewhere in Somalia, aka, Randistan. In the meantime, we should undertake a concerted effort to find the body of Tom Paine, and restore it to its proper place of honor.










