
I am struggling with an even deep[er] anti-Reaganian ideal – that beyond a certain natural limit, it is impossible to “earn” money. It’s an invitation to totalitarianism, I know. But the primary means of earning large sums of money are due to inheritance, scaling, and mere proximity.
Scaling is the ability to take a product sold one-on-one, and repeat the act of selling that product without additional effort. Effort is involved in writing a computer program, scaling comes about when you have the ability to market it by merely putting up a web site . If you are a writer you can read your writing to someone and charge a fee, read it to a large group and collect a number of fees at once, or get it published, like Dan Brown, and watch the public engage in a crap-feast.
Hard to quantify, but pure luck has a lot to do with rewards in that type of activity. How many authors better than Dan Brown never get published?
And then there is proximity – this includes inheritance, but also banking, real estate – any type of transaction where you can place yourself at a bottleneck and charge for passage of that money from one set of hands to another. There’s a lot of calculating in that, but not what I would call socially useful skill. As a banker you are managing other people’s money, and charging a fee for taking from one group and lending to another. Whoopti-doo. That ‘skill’ would not amount to a dime’s worth of income were it not for the fact that the banker is close to the money.
There’s a whole class of people who are merely in the hunt for bottlenecks. We call them “entrepreneurs”, but that is something else entirely. These people don’t invent, they merely fence off goods or services and charge for use – wireless Internet or cell phones are a good example – the “skill” involved in those activities comes from lawyers who rope us into complex contracts of little benefit to us, but huge benefit to the people who stand at the bottleneck.
It’s a part of my justification for high tax rates on high incomes – the idea that for the most part, high income is due to clever calculating without much societal benefit in the outcome, or mere luck. From a moral standpoint, I can justify high taxes on high incomes if we allow people to avoid those taxes by doing socially useful things with their money, like investing in plants and equipment and people, or giving it to charity. You [know], like in the 1950′s, when we had a better system of shared prosperity than now.

There was a concept in play up until Reagan took office, a distinction between “earned” income (wages, self-employment) and “passive” income (interest, dividends, royalties, etc). Passive income was taxed at higher rates than earned income.
Republicans, tools that they are, are now promoting the idea that passive income ought to be exempt in total from taxation. It’s perverse, but a natural product of the idea that mere proximity is the same as earning, and therefore ought to enjoy privilege. Indeed there should be a reward for saving and setting aside for one’s future, but this should not be confounded with inheritance, luck, and proximity. God what weird times we live in.













