In the prior piece regarding an article printed in a local news tabloid, brevity was the rule. I could not deal with everything put forward by Allen Best in his 10/22/26 piece titled “Chapters: As a coal mine closes, solar comes in”. So I had to ignore a thing or two put forth by Mr. Best, including the following passage:
“Storage will help. Platte River [Power Authority] expects the 100-megawatt four-hour discharge lithium-ion-phosphate storage nest to Black Hollow Solar to be completed in December [2026]”
Let’s do some math. Skip ahead if you are not so inclined, though that will leave only two lines of text to read. God bless you, you are spared!
A megawatt is enough energy to light ten thousand 100 watt incandescent bulbs for one hour, so a 100-MW facility would light one million bulbs for one hour. How Mr. Best gets four hours out of a 100-megawatts facility is probably due to grid-scale batteries storing perhaps four times the energy as residential. The storage facility will back up a solar array that produces 257 Mw (megawatts) daily, supplying 73,000 homes, so that the battery storage facility, in the case of a total array breakdown (think snow storm), would supply about nine hours of electricity to those homes. Maybe enough, though last year our area was out of power for three days due to high winds.
Continues Mr. Best:
“To the dismay of some environmental advocates, most utilities want natural gas as a backup. For example, Platte River is spending $600 million on a plant that uses newer technology that can generate electricity almost instantly as needed to balance the variability of renewables.”
My question: Why spend $600 million on an extremely efficient natural gas plant to back up an extremely inefficient $472 million solar one? Why not just go straight to natural gas, and junk the solar panels (which, by the way, do not recycle easily. It costs about $20 now to recover $12-14 of raw materials from panels.).
The idea that we can use lithium-iron batteries to store energy is, to say the least, quaint. What, after all, are hydrocarbon fuels about, if not energy storage? Natural gas, coal, oil, uranium in the ground are stored energy!
Here’s a few details, keeping in mind that there are tremendous capital costs in building solar, natural gas, oil, coal and nuclear facilities. There’s a rule of thumb at work here for all, that economies of scale reduce the per unit costs for any factory. It may cost more to build a natural gas facility than a solar array, but natural gas is 100% efficient where solar is, in this case, at best 27% efficient. In the long run, gas is cheaper.
I will deal only with raw materials here, setting capital investment aside, and try to reduce all to “BTU”, or equivalent British Thermal Units, as a measure of energy (a BTU is enough energy to heat one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit):
- A 100 megawatt facility with a four hour discharge duration (Mr. Best’s facility) stores 400 megawatt hours of energy. There are about 3,412 BTU per KWh, so that the facility stores 1.365 million BTU of energy (400 x 3412).
- One MMBtu of natural gas (1000 btu) contains by definition one million BTU of energy, or 73% of the total daily output of Mr. Best’s facility. The price of one MMBtu of gas right now is about $3.40. Yes, you read that right – $3.40 of natural gas can supply 76% the of nine hours output of the $50 million Platte River Battery storage facility.
- One barrel of crude oil holds about 5.8 million BTU, or over four times the capacity of the Platte River Battery Storage Facility. One barrel of oil now runs around $90.
- One ton of coal provides on average 20.3 million BTU of energy, or almost 15 times the energy of the Platte River Battery Storage Facility,
- and costs on average $400
- One pound of uranium-235 provides 37,000,000,000,000 joules of energy, or One joule = .0009478171 BTU, so that one pound of uranium provides an unimaginable 35,063,233,345 BTU of energy, or enough to supply about 3.5 million homes one year of energy. (Why did we cast this aside?)
In other words, gas, oil, coal and nuclear electrical generation, which do not require battery backup, are perhaps more expensive in the offing, but can you begin to grasp their production potential? Compared to solar, natural gas and nuclear are far more efficient, a no-brainer..
The climate change crowd to claims that solar energy is cheaper, which is mind-boggling given that they cannot begin to produce enough of it (not to mention integrating direct current solar power into an alternating current grid. Maybe the daily cost of running a solar facility is less than hydrocarbon or nuclear fuel facilities, but we lack the land and resources to get enough of them up and running, and anyway, solar is not a reliable energy producer, no matter the cost. Without massive public subsidy, solar power does not even exist except to perhaps run pumps on small wells on farms and ranches or flashing lights that are located away from regular power sources. That’s what solar is good for, or to perhaps run the garage door opener on Al Gore’s Tennessee mansion.
I cannot help but take note here that 1) doing the math on nuclear energy was overwhelming, as if there must be a mistake somewhere!, and 2) had nuclear been allowed to catch on, we would all enjoy cheap abundant and safe electricity now, and that the Climate Change alarmists’ eschewing of nuclear is a huge defect that exposes their true objectives as having nothing to do with energy.
With all of that in mind, can we please come to our senses? We are talking about spending $50 million on a battery storage facility that can supply perhaps 1/250 of the energy of one pound of uranium, and we are talking about it like it is an advance in technology! Have we lost our minds?